
To say I have no empathy for Ted Haggard would place me alongside his more spiritual, vengeful, unforgiving followers who defrocked and banished him, his family, from his own New Life [Mega]Church in Colorado. This is, first and foremost, a story about how the Church treats its own.
Not a new story. Gays have been killed, wished dead, tossed out of their families for centuries. If not in the name of Christ, in the name of whatever evil, authoritarian church/state executes power over our own bodies.
If Christ is a liberator, nobody told American Evangelicals.
It’s also the age-old story of living the double life of a liar. Ted Haggard clearly had good reasons to lie. I mean, come on, all gays know they’ve got to lie to live, let alone to get anywhere in this world. This is “don’t ask, don’t tell”, “I believe marriage is between one man and one woman” (in successive attempts), America. You don’t want people to know. To find out. Not your family. Not your job. Not your church, for crissakes. I mean, you just know what they’ll do to you. They’ll strip you. You’ll lose it all. You’ll lose everything.
They’ll crucify you. (Again, not a new story).
I don’t know Mr. Haggard. We’ve never met outside of his rather sizable media reach. Based on his television persona alone, this is not a man I would seek to share closeness with or befriend. To me, he puts the snake in snake oil. Still, he got tens of thousands, perhaps millions, to believe in his lie. Not the truth in Christ that sets the captive free, but the lie that you can’t be a man and lie down with another man and live freely, openly, to tell the story.
You can’t be gay like Jesus.
(O Mary, don’t ask.)
So, once again, we have a story of a man who cheated, lived a lie, duped his family, parishioners, told countless of thousands of gay kids to “fight the good fight” (or die trying), selling his empty bag of goods, quotable sound bites, biblical gumdrops to cherry-picked tow-the-hard-line believers who never falter in the truth…
but are always caught in the lie.
Ted, I don’t blame you for lying. For believing the lies. For becoming a real good liar. A great liar. Top of your game “truth pedlar.” There’s some unique, albeit disingenuous, craft in that.
And, I don’t blame you for so badly wanting to be straight. To continue to sit the same pew with the people who compare you to murderers. Lower than murderers. Hitler. Scum. Exiling you and your family to perish. Fend for yourselves.
Hell, I’d even forgive you for denying Christ a third time. You can live in denial for the rest of your god-given, life insurance selling days.
But I’d never ask even one of my gay (or non-gay) sisters, brothers, to pick up their nets and follow you.